01Signs that your site needs a change

The usual signs are a site that does not work well on a phone, that is slow, that uses a generic theme, that no longer converts, or that you cannot edit without fighting the builder. None of those alone says whether to redesign or to build a new one: that comes from the questions below.

Fig. 1 · The 7 questions: redesign or a new site

02The 7 questions: redesign or a new site

Each question points one way or the other. In a diagnosis they are answered from what is on your site, not from a general recipe.

1. Does the platform still work? If the current technology can be maintained and extended, a redesign in place is often enough. If it is abandoned or cannot be updated safely, it is cleaner to build a new site and redirect.

2. Can you manage it yourself? If you already edit it comfortably and the problem is visual or about clarity, it can be redesigned on top. If every change needs a technician or the builder, a new self-managed site is usually the path.

3. Which URLs already rank? If there is a clear set of pages that already rank, they are kept or redirected with 301s, in a redesign and in a new site. That inventory is done before the decision.

4. Has your offer changed? If the business is still the same and the site is only dated, a redesign fits. If the offer has changed so much that the architecture no longer works, a new site is the better path.

5. Do you need more than one language? Languages can be added in a redesign or in a new site. What matters is including them in the scope from the start, not as an add-on at the end.

6. Are you stuck on a builder? Wix, Squarespace and other builders are fine until they limit you. If you cannot leave their theme, their payments or their editing model, the path is usually a new site, not a redesign on top of the builder.

7. Do you need product features (bookings, a client area)? If people have to do something in the product — book, log in, manage an account — a brochure site is not enough. That is a custom platform, and it is planned as one.

03Comparison: redesign, new site and custom platform

RedesignNew siteCustom platform
When it fitsThe platform still works and the problem is the look, mobile or clarityThe builder or the technology is in the way, or the architecture no longer fitsPeople need to book, log in or run a process, not only read the offer
What is keptStructure and URLs when they still serveContent and ranking URLs, redirectedThe business rules and the data the product needs
SEO301s if a URL changes; metadata alignedA 301 table from the inventoryThe same as a new site, plus the product URLs
AfterwardsCan be left self-managedBuilt so you can edit it yourselfDelivered in phases; maintenance is agreed
Fig. 2 · How not to lose SEO in either case

04How not to lose SEO in either case

Whether you redesign or build a new site, the essential work is the same: inventory the URLs that rank, redirect the ones that change with 301s, and align titles, descriptions, canonicals and the sitemap with the new structure.

That does not guarantee rankings. It avoids throwing away what the current site already has.

05What a diagnosis delivers before you decide

A diagnosis is a short review of the current site, how you edit it and what already ranks. You leave with the decision (redesign, new site or platform), the risks and the scope, in writing. You can stop after that step.

The website and shop redesign service covers both a redesign and a new site, including the 301 redirects that are needed.

If the project is a store migration, also use the checklist on how to migrate an online store without losing SEO.